Skip to content
Main Menu

Home How It Works The HRPP Review Process Ongoing Submissions and Amendments for Studies Relying on an External IRB

Ongoing Submissions and Amendments for Studies Relying on an External IRB


When the University of Utah is relying on an external single IRB, what changes must still be submitted to the University of Utah Human Research Protection Program (HRPP)?

When the University of Utah relies on an external single IRB, that IRB becomes the Reviewing IRB for the study. The Reviewing IRB is the external single IRB serving as the IRB of record.

The Reviewing IRB reviews and approves most study changes. The University of Utah Human Research Protection Program, or HRPP, continues to oversee local institutional requirements.

This means you should not submit every Reviewing IRB amendment to the Utah HRPP.

You only need to submit changes that affect University of Utah personnel, local requirements, or other institutional responsibilities. The Reviewing IRB remains responsible for reviewing changes to the research. The Lead Study Team submits both study-wide and site-specific amendments to the Reviewing IRB. Always follow the study’s communication plan and Reviewing IRB instructions.

Important: Reviewing IRB approval does not replace required University of Utah institutional reviews. ALWAYS coordinate through your Lead Study Team.

Learn more about the HRPP review process


Start Here: Does the Change Require Utah HRPP Review?

Submit the change in ERICA if it affects:

  • The Utah Site Investigator or key study personnel
  • A Utah law, policy, standard, or institutional requirement
  • A local or other consideration previously communicated to the Reviewing IRB
  • Utah HIPAA or privacy responsibilities
  • A local COI determination or management plan
  • A required Utah ancillary review
  • Utah-specific study conduct or participant-facing materials
  • Funding or other information Utah requires ERICA to maintain

Did the change affect only University of Utah activities or local institutional requirements?
If Yes, then Submit to Utah HRPP
If No, then Follow Reviewing IRB process only


Changes You Must Submit to the Utah HRPP

When relying on an external IRB, Utah may conduct:

  • Administrative review
  • Personnel verification
  • COI review
  • Ancillary review
  • Privacy or HIPAA review
  • Institutional authorization
  • Local acknowledgment

IRB approval is reserved for the Reviewing IRB or if applicable, a separate local approval authority.

Submit an amendment in ERICA when a change affects a University of Utah responsibility described below.

  • Submit changes involving University of Utah study personnel, including:

    • Adding or removing local study personnel
    • Changing the University of Utah Principal Investigator
    • Changing local personnel roles when the change affects study responsibilities
    • Updating information needed to document local qualifications or training

    Relying institutions have a role in authorizing changes to site investigators and key personnel. The local institution confirms qualifications, training, and available resources.

    Do not include personnel changes from other institutions unless the information appears in a Utah-specific field or document that must remain current. Reliance is established between institutions, so a Principal Investigator change at another site does not usually require a Utah amendment.

  • Submit new or revised recruitment materials created specifically for the University of Utah site.

    Examples include:

    • A Utah-specific recruitment letter
    • A local recruitment method not addressed by the study-wide materials
    • Materials created to meet a University of Utah requirement
    • A local recruitment approach that differs from other study sites

    You usually do not need to submit sponsor-created or study-wide recruitment materials separately. This includes materials customized only with local contact information.

  • Submit changes involving local privacy or data requirements, including:

    • University of Utah HIPAA Authorization language
    • Local HIPAA disclosures
    • Local access to protected health information
    • Utah-specific privacy protections
    • Local data-use or information-security requirements

    Relying institutions have the responsibility to enforce restrictions on the use and disclosure of protected health information maintained by their own covered entity.

  • Submit changes to funding or other institutional information when University policy requires the information to remain current in ERICA.

    Examples may include:

    • Adding or removing a funding source
    • Changing the local sponsor or funding relationship
    • Updating information that triggers a Utah institutional review

    These are Utah institutional requirements, and may be considered differently by your SIRB.

  • Submit changes involving a new or revised local conflict of interest determination.

    The University may need to:

    • Review a new potential conflict
    • Update a management plan
    • Determine whether the conflict affects the reliance arrangement
    • Communicate relevant requirements to the Reviewing IRB

    Relying institutions need to assess new potential conflicts and determine whether local action is needed.

  • Submit changes that introduce or affect a local consideration.

    Local considerations may include:

    • Utah laws and regulations
    • University of Utah policies or standards
    • Local ancillary reviews
    • Local consent requirements
    • Institutional restrictions
    • Local facilities, resources, or operational requirements

    The University of Utah remains responsible for identifying and communicating local requirements throughout the study. The Reviewing IRB considers those requirements during its review.

  • Submit corrective actions when they change Utah study conduct, affect information maintained in ERICA, or require Utah institutional review. Also follow the Reviewing IRB’s reporting and amendment requirements.

    Examples include:

    • Changes required after a local compliance review
    • Actions resulting from a local noncompliance determination
    • Updates needed to satisfy a University oversight requirement
    • Revisions connected to a local ancillary review

Changes You Usually Do Not Submit to the Utah HRPP

Do not submit a separate Utah amendment when the change is study-wide and does not affect a University of Utah responsibility.

  • These changes usually require Reviewing IRB approval only:

    • Eligibility criteria changes
    • Study procedure changes
    • Schedule of events revisions
    • Study design changes
    • Statistical analysis changes
    • Study-wide safety updates
    • Study-wide consent revisions

    The Reviewing IRB conducts the regulatory review of study-wide changes. A relying HRPP should avoid repeating that review.

  • You usually do not need to submit:

    • Lead-site personnel changes
    • Principal Investigator changes at another institution
    • Personnel changes at another relying site
    • Coordinating-center personnel changes
    • Administrative changes that do not affect Utah

    Update Utah records only when the change affects information maintained for local purposes.

  • You usually do not need to submit:

    • Sponsor-created recruitment materials
    • Study-wide participant letters
    • Study-wide surveys or questionnaires
    • Study-wide consent documents
    • Materials already approved for all sites by the Reviewing IRB

    Submit these materials locally only when they introduce or affect a Utah-specific requirement.

  • A separate Utah amendment is generally unnecessary when customization only involves:

    • A local telephone number
    • A local email address
    • A Utah investigator’s name
    • Standard local contact information

    Utah HRPP review is generally not required when an approved study-wide material is customized only with standard Utah contact information.

    Follow the Reviewing IRB’s requirements for making or approving these substitutions. Some Reviewing IRBs permit defined administrative changes without a new amendment.


Common Examples

Example 1: Study-Wide Eligibility Change

The sponsor changes the study’s inclusion criteria at every participating site.

What to do:
  • Follow the Reviewing IRB’s amendment process.
  • Do not submit a Utah amendment unless the change affects a local requirement.
  • Use the Reviewing IRB-approved protocol when authorized for implementation.
Example 2: New Utah Study Coordinator

The Utah site adds a new research coordinator.

What to do:
  • Submit a personnel amendment in ERICA.
  • Complete applicable local training and qualification requirements.
  • Follow the Reviewing IRB’s personnel process, if required.
Example 3: Principal Investigator Change at the Lead Site

The lead institution appoints a new Principal Investigator.

What to do:
  • Follow communications from the lead study team and Reviewing IRB.
  • Do not submit a Utah amendment solely because another site changed investigators.
  • Update Utah documents only when they contain information that must remain current.
Example 4: Sponsor-Created Recruitment Flyer

The sponsor creates a recruitment flyer for all participating sites. The Utah version only includes a local telephone number.

What to do:
  • Follow the Reviewing IRB’s instructions for adding local contact information.
  • Do not submit a Utah HRPP amendment unless the change affects a Utah requirement or recruitment approach.
Example 5: Utah-Specific Recruitment Letter

The Utah site creates a recruitment letter to address a University policy. Other sites will not use the letter.

What to do:
  • Submit the document according to the Reviewing IRB’s process.
  • Submit an amendment to the Utah HRPP.
  • Do not use the letter until all required reviews are complete.
Example 6: Study-Wide Consent Revision

The Reviewing IRB approves a revised consent form for every site. Do not independently revise the Reviewing IRB-approved consent document. Coordinate Utah-required language through the Lead Study Team and Reviewing IRB.

What to do:
  • Determine whether the revision affects Utah-specific consent language or local requirements.
  • Submit to the Utah HRPP only if a local requirement is affected.
  • Replace prior versions with the current approved version.
Example 7: Local HIPAA Language Change

The Utah site needs to revise language addressing local HIPAA disclosures.

What to do:
  • Submit an amendment to the Utah HRPP.
  • Follow the Reviewing IRB’s process for revising site-specific documents.
  • Use the revised document after all required reviews are complete.
Example 8: Funding Change

The study adds or changes a funding source documented in ERICA.

What to do:
  • Submit an amendment to update the Utah application.
  • Complete any additional University reviews triggered by the change.
  • Follow the Reviewing IRB’s requirements, when applicable.

Reviewing IRB Approval and Utah HRPP Review Serve Different Purposes

Reviewing IRB Approval

The Reviewing IRB:

  • Conducts the regulatory IRB review
  • Reviews study-wide and site-specific amendments
  • Approves changes to the research
  • Communicates its determinations
  • Provides approved study documents

Under SMART IRB’s default procedures, the lead study team serves as the central point for amendment submissions and distribution of approved materials.

Utah HRPP Review

The Utah HRPP:

  • Reviews University of Utah institutional requirements
  • Evaluates Utah-specific local considerations
  • Coordinates applicable local reviews
  • Maintains local HRPP records
  • Confirms that required institutional steps are complete

The Utah HRPP does not conduct a second regulatory IRB review of changes already approved by the Reviewing IRB. Local review focuses on institutional oversight rather than duplicating the Reviewing IRB’s work.


When Can We Implement a Change?

Reviewing IRB approval and local implementation are related, but they are not the same step. The Reviewing IRB approves the change. Utah determines whether required local institutional steps are complete before the change is implemented at the Utah site.

Do not describe Utah’s local action as a second IRB approval unless Utah is performing delegated IRB review under a documented arrangement.

Before implementing a change at the University of Utah:

  • Obtain Reviewing IRB approval when required.
  • Complete any required Utah HRPP submission.
  • Complete applicable ancillary or institutional reviews.
  • Confirm the site can implement the change as approved.
  • Train affected study personnel.
  • Replace outdated study documents.
  • Follow any implementation instructions from the Reviewing IRB or lead study team.

Do not delay an amendment submission to the Reviewing IRB while waiting for unrelated local reviews when the reviews can occur in parallel.

Contact the SIRB Reliance Team if the approved change cannot be implemented at Utah as written.


Amendments and Report Forms Are Different

An amendment updates the study application or approved study documents.

A Report Form notifies the Utah HRPP about an event, issue, or other reportable information.

For studies relying on an external IRB:

  • Only a limited group of changes requires a local amendment.
  • Utah’s local reporting requirements still apply.
  • The Reviewing IRB may have separate reporting requirements.
  • Investigators must follow both institutions’ reporting policies.

A change may not require a Utah amendment but may still require a Utah Report Form.

Review University of Utah Report Form requirements


How to Submit a Required Change

When a change requires Utah HRPP review:

  1. Open the study in ERICA.
  2. Create an amendment.
  3. Describe only the changes relevant to the University of Utah.
  4. Update the applicable sections of the Utah application.
  5. Attach relevant Utah-specific documents.
  6. Include Reviewing IRB documentation when applicable.
  7. Submit the amendment through the applicable ERICA workflow.

Do not include unrelated study-wide changes in the Utah amendment. This helps the HRPP identify and review the local changes efficiently.


Quick Reference

Submit to the Utah HRPP

  • Utah Principal Investigator changes
  • Local personnel changes
  • Utah-specific recruitment materials or methods
  • Local HIPAA or privacy changes
  • Funding changes documented in ERICA
  • New or revised local conflict of interest requirements
  • Changes affecting Utah laws or University policies
  • Changes requiring local ancillary review
  • Local corrective actions or compliance requirements

Usually Do Not Submit to the Utah HRPP

  • Study-wide protocol amendments
  • Study-wide eligibility changes
  • Study-wide consent revisions without local impact
  • Sponsor-created recruitment materials
  • Materials customized only with local contact information
  • Personnel changes at another institution
  • Lead-site Principal Investigator changes
  • Other changes that do not affect Utah responsibilities

Questions?

If you are unsure whether a change requires Utah HRPP review:

  • Review the activation letter issued through ERICA.
  • Check the study’s reliance and communication documentation.
  • Contact the SIRB Reliance Team before creating an amendment.

When contacting the team, include:

  • The Utah IRB number
  • A short description of the change
  • The Reviewing IRB’s amendment or approval letter, if available
  • Any revised Utah-specific documents

Clear information helps the team determine whether Utah HRPP review is required.

Do you need assistance from our team?

Contact Us